{
  "schema": "varexis-public-evidence-record/0.3",
  "generated_at_utc": "2026-10-31T14:11:02.820224+00:00",
  "record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE12-MCP-SCOPE-UPGRADE-RETRY-BUDGET-01-v1",
  "record_kind": "external_reference",
  "title": "MCP repeated scope-challenge retry boundary",
  "system": "Model Context Protocol",
  "evidence_family": "vendor_evidence_review",
  "index_status": "PUBLIC_SAFE_SOURCE_REVIEW",
  "evidence_state": "PRIMARY_DOCUMENTATION_REVIEW_ONLY",
  "canonical_question": "How long should an MCP client keep retrying after repeated insufficient_scope challenges?",
  "near_questions": [
    "When should repeated MCP scope upgrade attempts stop?",
    "Does MCP specify an exact insufficient_scope retry count?",
    "Should MCP authorisation retry limits be tracked per operation?",
    "Can an agent keep widening scopes until an MCP request succeeds?"
  ],
  "supported_claims": [
    {
      "claim": "MCP 2026-07-28 describes retrying the original request with new authorisation only a few times before treating it as a permanent authorisation failure. It recommends retry limits and tracking scope-upgrade attempts for the same resource and operation. The specification does not supply one universal numeric retry count.",
      "reliance": "DOCUMENTED_CAPABILITY_ONLY"
    }
  ],
  "not_demonstrated_claims": [
    "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute.",
    "Buyer implementation, live runtime enforcement, settled payment, verified deletion or certification are not established.",
    "No expanded capabilities or licences for existing INDEX executables."
  ],
  "public_summary": "MCP 2026-07-28 describes retrying the original request with new authorisation only a few times before treating it as a permanent authorisation failure. It recommends retry limits and tracking scope-upgrade attempts for the same resource and operation. The specification does not supply one universal numeric retry count.",
  "related_record_ids": [],
  "source_review": {
    "source_type": "official_external_documentation",
    "source_title": "MCP HTTP authorization, specification 2026-07-28",
    "source_url": "https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/authorization.md",
    "checked_on": "2026-10-31",
    "candidate_record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE12-MCP-SCOPE-UPGRADE-RETRY-BUDGET-01-v1",
    "candidate_record_sha256": "e7352195b26f83f21ef5e3b6c574e5fc4f836d703c87cb54f4d2006c97bb3537",
    "method": "Primary documentation reviewed for the published bounded statement.",
    "deployment_tested_by_varexis": false,
    "revalidation": "The delivered snapshot preserves the review date shown. Recheck current primary documentation and deployment context before relying on present applicability; payment does not trigger fresh research."
  },
  "answer_policy": {
    "classification": "DOCUMENTED_WITH_DEPLOYMENT_BOUNDARY",
    "bounded_answer": "MCP 2026-07-28 describes retrying the original request with new authorisation only a few times before treating it as a permanent authorisation failure. It recommends retry limits and tracking scope-upgrade attempts for the same resource and operation. The specification does not supply one universal numeric retry count.",
    "required_buyer_context": "resource/operation and sanitised challenge sequence; configured retry cap and tracked scope-upgrade attempts; grant outcomes, terminal refusal and separate action evidence. Buyer deployment not inspected.",
    "missing_evidence": "A broader claim needs evidence matching the intended use. Payment does not upgrade the evidence state."
  },
  "private_boundary": "Raw logs, thresholds, private paths, source code, protected mechanisms and reconstruction-level details are excluded from public and paid delivery.",
  "decision_profile": {
    "schema": "varexis-vendor-evidence-review/1",
    "review_status": "documentation_review_only",
    "applicability_status": "MCP specification 2026-07-28; recommended tracking and qualitative retry bound do not imply a mandated fixed number. Review capture 2026-10-31. Buyer deployment not inspected.",
    "checked_on": "2026-10-31",
    "claim_to_check": "How long should an MCP client keep retrying after repeated insufficient_scope challenges?",
    "documented_statement": {
      "status": "documented",
      "statement": "MCP 2026-07-28 describes retrying the original request with new authorisation only a few times before treating it as a permanent authorisation failure. It recommends retry limits and tracking scope-upgrade attempts for the same resource and operation. The specification does not supply one universal numeric retry count.",
      "source_ids": [
        "mcp-auth"
      ]
    },
    "review_inference": {
      "status": "review_inference",
      "statement": "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute. The existing record caps request duration despite progress. This review bounds repeated authority upgrades and retries by resource/operation, a different failure and refusal decision from transport timeout. Operational review inference; no deployment outcome was observed.",
      "source_ids": [
        "mcp-auth"
      ]
    },
    "buyer_evidence_required": [
      "resource/operation and sanitised challenge sequence",
      "configured retry cap and tracked scope-upgrade attempts",
      "grant outcomes, terminal refusal and separate action evidence"
    ],
    "review_condition": {
      "status": "varexis_review_policy",
      "statement": "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute."
    },
    "unknowns": "Buyer implementation, installed versions, effective authority, source completeness and actual business outcomes were not inspected.",
    "unknown_finding": {
      "status": "unknown",
      "statement": "No buyer deployment or transaction was observed."
    },
    "evidence_sources": [
      {
        "source_id": "mcp-auth",
        "url": "https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/authorization.md",
        "final_url": "https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/authorization.md",
        "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-31T14:07:23.008429+00:00",
        "status": 200,
        "content_type": "text/markdown; charset=utf-8",
        "bytes": 25510,
        "sha256": "59bc8d07ef88538e4d4e539ca1c846c3ae3162e7911dc29453495cddeac18444",
        "title": "MCP HTTP authorization, specification 2026-07-28",
        "publisher": "Model Context Protocol",
        "checked_on": "2026-10-31",
        "capture_status": "captured_primary_documentation",
        "claim_review_completed": true,
        "hash_basis": "Raw HTTP response bytes retained privately; not deployment attestation.",
        "version_context": "MCP specification 2026-07-28",
        "rights_disposition": "Original bounded paraphrase with source attribution. Full source capture remains private; no source code, examples or vendor documentation is redistributed. Anthropic repository MIT licensing and IETF source notices remain with original sources.",
        "reviewed_sections": [
          "Step-Up Authorization Flow",
          "previously requested scope set",
          "Retry the original request",
          "same resource and operation"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "observed_deployment": false,
    "commercial_reliance_boundary": "Documentation supports only the stated boundary. Existing licensed checkers analyse supported supplied declarations locally; they do not inspect provider accounts, verify live behaviour, enforce decisions or certify compliance.",
    "paid_value": {
      "decision_context": "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute.",
      "free": "Complete source review, questions, provenance and limitations; free to read and save locally.",
      "single_request": "Unavailable for this publication-only record; historical saved retrieval is unchanged.",
      "evidence_receipt": "Unavailable for this publication-only record; no paid retrieval entitlement is added.",
      "excluded": [
        "Fresh source research",
        "Native provider integration or schema support",
        "Live inspection or runtime enforcement",
        "Payment settlement or verified deletion",
        "Certification or expanded licences"
      ],
      "integrity": "Hashes identify content versions; they do not prove factual truth or provide a signature."
    },
    "revalidation": {
      "trigger": "Recheck current primary documentation and applicable SDK, service and configuration before reliance. No ongoing monitoring is included.",
      "specific_watch": "Retry the original request; same resource and operation"
    },
    "buyer_relevance": "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute.",
    "refusal_conditions": [
      "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute.",
      "Do not infer deployment conformance, authority or successful outcomes from source documentation."
    ],
    "decision_context": {
      "operator": "Developer or reviewer assessing agent execution and evidence",
      "scenario": "How long should an MCP client keep retrying after repeated insufficient_scope challenges?",
      "consequence": "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute.",
      "confidence": "Primary-documentation support only; buyer demand and deployment outcomes unestablished."
    },
    "novelty_review": {
      "candidate_id": "ICE12-10",
      "disposition": "new_distinct",
      "nearest_record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE11-MCP-PROGRESS-RESET-MAXIMUM-DEADLINE-01-v1",
      "nearest_record_url": "/varexis-index/records/mcp-progress-reset-maximum-deadline.json",
      "nearest_record_sha256": "354f295e61f46727cc517edbac9fff94e2b143190ff9763620a8cdb92181bb1c",
      "material_distinction": "The existing record caps request duration despite progress. This review bounds repeated authority upgrades and retries by resource/operation, a different failure and refusal decision from transport timeout.",
      "review_status": "Primary-source review and full adjacent-record comparison; no independent challenge claimed."
    },
    "optional_selection": {
      "guide_id": "delegated-agent-identity-continuity",
      "guide_url": "/index-guides/delegated-agent-identity-continuity",
      "guide_manifest": "/varexis-index/decision-guides.json",
      "checker": {
        "product_id": "agent-tool-admission",
        "price_gbp_excluding_vat": 49,
        "purchase_url": "/index-access?route=agentic_pack_tool_admission_v1",
        "licence_scope": "Existing separate internal-use licence; subscriptions do not include the executable.",
        "benefit": "Optional local analysis of supported supplied declarations only; no native Claude SDK or MCP integration is added."
      },
      "boundary": "This free record supports an evidence-selection decision. The existing checker does not diagnose these platforms, extract their logs or prove the documented condition occurred."
    },
    "exact_access": {
      "endpoint": "/mcp/catalogue",
      "tool": "get_publication_record",
      "arguments": {
        "record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE12-MCP-SCOPE-UPGRADE-RETRY-BUDGET-01-v1"
      },
      "record_url": "/varexis-index/records/mcp-scope-upgrade-retry-budget.json",
      "original_mcp_search": false,
      "paid_saved_retrieval": false
    }
  },
  "niche": {
    "niche_id": "ice12-identity",
    "label": "Agent Identity, Credentials & Delegation",
    "classification_id": "identity",
    "classification_label": "Agent Identity, Credentials & Delegation",
    "topic_id": "identity",
    "buyer_intent": "Refuse unbounded reauthorisation loops or automatic widening of authority to make a request pass. Set and record a bounded policy, stop on exhaustion and retain sanitised failure evidence. This limit does not establish idempotency or prove a prior business action did not execute.",
    "comparison_role": "supplementary_discovery"
  },
  "paid_access_note": "The full published answer and boundaries are free. Paid access saves the selected route and source versions, with an unsigned receipt when purchased. Preview coverage before paying. Fresh research, bespoke assessment and protected evidence are excluded.",
  "service_route": {
    "request_guide": "/varexis-index/request.html",
    "request_workflow": "/varexis-index/request-workflow.json",
    "service_id": "single_request",
    "service_routes_url": "/varexis-index/service-routes.json",
    "payment_required": true,
    "availability_endpoint": "/api/index/capabilities",
    "operational_status": "AUTOMATIC_SERVICE_CAPABILITIES_GATED",
    "checkout_url": "/index-access"
  },
  "authority_boundary": "VAREXIS-INDEX informs evidence reliance. It does not provide advice, certification, deployment authority, security assurance, production approval, or guarantee.",
  "human_page": "/varexis-index/catalog.html#mcp-scope-upgrade-retry-budget",
  "machine_readable_record": "/varexis-index/records/mcp-scope-upgrade-retry-budget.json"
}