{ "schema": "varexis-index-free-publication-preview/1", "catalogue_version": "pub-1-tranche-51-v1", "route_id": "agentic_reviewed_x402_mcp_payment_error_after_tool_execution", "record_id": "VXI-EXT-PROCUREMENT-X402-MCP-PAYMENT-ERROR-AFTER-TOOL-EXECUTION-01-v1", "question": "Does an x402 MCP payment error prove that the tool did not execute?", "answer": "The reviewed MCP transport uses isError tool results for payment requirements and failures. It specifically covers settlement failing after tool execution and says the tool content should then be withheld. An error result therefore does not establish absence of a prior tool effect; the failure phase matters.", "records": [ { "record_id": "VXI-EXT-PROCUREMENT-X402-MCP-PAYMENT-ERROR-AFTER-TOOL-EXECUTION-01-v1", "url": "/varexis-index/records/x402-mcp-payment-error-after-tool-execution.json", "content_sha256": "b22dd8d4f5e946457ed29d86324c664668fd96a3611d1e03995b8ef5c55be358", "evidence": { "schema": "varexis-public-evidence-record/0.3", "generated_at_utc": "2026-10-24T21:35:02.243Z", "record_id": "VXI-EXT-PROCUREMENT-X402-MCP-PAYMENT-ERROR-AFTER-TOOL-EXECUTION-01-v1", "record_kind": "external_reference", "title": "x402 MCP settlement failure and prior execution", "system": "x402 Foundation", "evidence_family": "vendor_evidence_review", "index_status": "PUBLIC_SAFE_SOURCE_REVIEW", "evidence_state": "PRIMARY_DOCUMENTATION_REVIEW_ONLY", "canonical_question": "Does an x402 MCP payment error prove that the tool did not execute?", "near_questions": [ "Can a paid MCP tool run before settlement fails?", "Does x402 MCP isError guarantee no side effect?", "Why can an x402 MCP error omit completed tool output?", "What should be reconciled before retrying a paid MCP tool?" ], "supported_claims": [ { "claim": "The reviewed MCP transport uses isError tool results for payment requirements and failures. It specifically covers settlement failing after tool execution and says the tool content should then be withheld. An error result therefore does not establish absence of a prior tool effect; the failure phase matters.", "reliance": "DOCUMENTED_CAPABILITY_ONLY" } ], "not_demonstrated_claims": [ "Independent verification of payment, delivery or deployed controls", "No actual tool effects or server retry protections have been inspected.", "Buyer deployment testing, live runtime enforcement, certification or permission to act", "Expanded capabilities or licences for existing INDEX executables" ], "public_summary": "The reviewed MCP transport uses isError tool results for payment requirements and failures. It specifically covers settlement failing after tool execution and says the tool content should then be withheld. An error result therefore does not establish absence of a prior tool effect; the failure phase matters.", "related_record_ids": [], "source_review": { "source_type": "official_external_documentation", "source_title": "Transport: MCP (Model Context Protocol)", "source_url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/x402-foundation/x402/4241d56cae2fb7ed06cd18e3a9ff2a3457b1ce54/specs/transports-v2/mcp.md", "checked_on": "2026-10-24", "candidate_record_id": "VXI-EXT-PROCUREMENT-X402-MCP-PAYMENT-ERROR-AFTER-TOOL-EXECUTION-01-v1", "candidate_record_sha256": "fbe0c2d59c472af5949bea3788cd95e29de8506c1634ec6980971b1aad38b2a9", "method": "Primary documentation reviewed for the published bounded statement.", "deployment_tested_by_varexis": false, "revalidation": "The delivered snapshot preserves the review date shown. Recheck current primary documentation and deployment context before relying on present applicability; payment does not trigger fresh research." }, "answer_policy": { "classification": "DOCUMENTED_WITH_DEPLOYMENT_BOUNDARY", "bounded_answer": "The reviewed MCP transport uses isError tool results for payment requirements and failures. It specifically covers settlement failing after tool execution and says the tool content should then be withheld. An error result therefore does not establish absence of a prior tool effect; the failure phase matters.", "required_buyer_context": "Tool request and stable operation identity; Verification, execution and settlement phase records; Tool effect evidence and retry policy. Buyer deployment not inspected.", "missing_evidence": "A broader claim needs evidence matching the intended use. Payment does not upgrade the evidence state." }, "private_boundary": "Raw logs, thresholds, private paths, source code, protected mechanisms and reconstruction-level details are excluded from public and paid delivery.", "decision_profile": { "schema": "varexis-vendor-evidence-review/1", "review_status": "documentation_review_only", "checked_on": "2026-10-24", "claim_to_check": "Does an x402 MCP payment error prove that the tool did not execute?", "documented_statement": { "status": "documented", "statement": "The reviewed MCP transport uses isError tool results for payment requirements and failures. It specifically covers settlement failing after tool execution and says the tool content should then be withheld. An error result therefore does not establish absence of a prior tool effect; the failure phase matters.", "source_ids": [ "x402-mcp" ] }, "review_inference": { "status": "review_inference", "statement": "Avoid repeating a side-effecting paid tool call based only on its error result. This is a review decision, not an observed buyer result.", "source_ids": [ "x402-mcp" ] }, "buyer_evidence_required": [ "Tool request and stable operation identity", "Verification, execution and settlement phase records", "Tool effect evidence and retry policy" ], "review_condition": { "status": "varexis_review_policy", "statement": "Do not infer no execution from an x402 MCP payment error alone." }, "unknowns": "No actual tool effects or server retry protections have been inspected.", "unknown_finding": { "status": "unknown", "statement": "No actual tool effects or server retry protections have been inspected." }, "evidence_sources": [ { "source_id": "x402-mcp", "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/x402-foundation/x402/4241d56cae2fb7ed06cd18e3a9ff2a3457b1ce54/specs/transports-v2/mcp.md", "final_url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/x402-foundation/x402/4241d56cae2fb7ed06cd18e3a9ff2a3457b1ce54/specs/transports-v2/mcp.md", "status": 200, "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-24T21:23:36.127Z", "sha256": "4f1e0bb50c60e3fe384142f589cd6323b8a9ec4432335ef29053d1220f9e2146", "bytes": 7622, "title": "Transport: MCP (Model Context Protocol)", "hash_basis": "Decoded HTTP response body bytes", "rights_review": "Original factual paraphrase and source metadata only; Apache-2.0 repository captures retained privately and not redistributed.", "checked_on": "2026-10-24", "capture_status": 200, "claim_review_completed": true, "reviewed_sections": [ "Settlement Failure", "Error Handling" ], "version_context": "Pinned x402-foundation/x402 revision 4241d56cae2fb7ed06cd18e3a9ff2a3457b1ce54 captured 2026-10-24. Documentation revision, not evidence that any buyer deployment conforms." } ], "observed_deployment": false, "commercial_reliance_boundary": "Documentation review only; the buyer must establish applicability and actual outcomes. INDEX does not inspect or control the deployment.", "paid_value": { "decision_context": "Avoid repeating a side-effecting paid tool call based only on its error result.", "free": "Complete review, sources, practical questions and limitations; may be saved locally.", "single_request": "Existing server-saved version-bound route snapshot for later authenticated retrieval.", "evidence_receipt": "The same snapshot plus the existing unsigned delivery receipt.", "excluded": [ "Fresh vendor research", "Continuous monitoring or change alerts", "Testing the buyer configuration", "Private evidence or vendor certification" ], "integrity": "Hashes identify content versions; they do not prove truth or provide a signature." }, "revalidation": { "trigger": "A saved purchase does not recheck the source or buyer configuration.", "specific_watch": "Recheck the pinned specification against the selected scheme, network, provider version and buyer evidence before relying on a current outcome." }, "buyer_relevance": "Avoid repeating a side-effecting paid tool call based only on its error result.", "refusal_conditions": [ "Do not infer no execution from an x402 MCP payment error alone." ] }, "niche": { "niche_id": "agent-authority-action-evidence", "label": "Agent Authority & Action Evidence", "classification_id": "payments", "classification_label": "Agent Payments, Authority & Transaction Evidence", "topic_id": "payments", "buyer_intent": "Avoid repeating a side-effecting paid tool call based only on its error result.", "comparison_role": "supplementary_discovery" }, "paid_access_note": "The full published answer and boundaries are free. Paid access saves the selected route and source versions, with an unsigned receipt when purchased. Preview coverage before paying. Fresh research, bespoke assessment and protected evidence are excluded.", "service_route": { "request_guide": "/varexis-index/request.html", "request_workflow": "/varexis-index/request-workflow.json", "service_id": "single_request", "service_routes_url": "/varexis-index/service-routes.json", "payment_required": true, "availability_endpoint": "/api/index/capabilities", "operational_status": "AUTOMATIC_SERVICE_CAPABILITIES_GATED", "checkout_url": "/index-access" }, "authority_boundary": "VAREXIS-INDEX informs evidence reliance. It does not provide advice, certification, deployment authority, security assurance, production approval, or guarantee.", "human_page": "/varexis-index/catalog.html#x402-mcp-payment-error-after-tool-execution", "machine_readable_record": "/varexis-index/records/x402-mcp-payment-error-after-tool-execution.json" } } ], "access": { "mode": "exact_http_only", "payment_required": false, "purchase_url": null, "mcp_preview_available": false, "paid_saved_retrieval_available": false, "natural_language_search_qualified": false }, "boundary": "Catalogue additions are available free through the exact HTTP JSON links below. Enhanced natural-language discovery is not yet qualified for these records. They are outside MCP search, MCP preview and paid saved retrieval. No search qualification, executable capability or entitlement is added.", "content_sha256": "543812193c374d9a8a407791e81472f7087563bd2a6d225db17080eb5500797f" }