{
  "schema": "varexis-index-free-publication-preview/1",
  "catalogue_version": "ice-09-tranche-68-v1",
  "route_id": "agentic_reviewed_mcp_scope_challenge_versus_advertised_scopes",
  "record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE09-MCP-SCOPE-CHALLENGE-VERSUS-ADVERTISED-SCOPES-01-v1",
  "question": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes?",
  "answer": "No. MCP 2026-07-28 prohibits assuming a set relationship between challenged scopes and scopes_supported, and requires treating the challenge as authoritative for the current operation. For initial authorization it recommends using the challenge scope first; otherwise it recommends advertised scopes, omitting scope when scopes_supported is undefined. This does not itself grant consent.",
  "records": [
    {
      "record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE09-MCP-SCOPE-CHALLENGE-VERSUS-ADVERTISED-SCOPES-01-v1",
      "url": "/varexis-index/records/mcp-scope-challenge-versus-advertised-scopes.json",
      "content_sha256": "209b8084db47e817ba82d6f9f85eed6dd0d0740300ec9fa8f2fa6333f109f6f9",
      "evidence": {
        "schema": "varexis-public-evidence-record/0.3",
        "generated_at_utc": "2026-10-30T15:17:58.235744+00:00",
        "record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE09-MCP-SCOPE-CHALLENGE-VERSUS-ADVERTISED-SCOPES-01-v1",
        "record_kind": "external_reference",
        "title": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes",
        "system": "Model Context Protocol",
        "evidence_family": "vendor_evidence_review",
        "index_status": "PUBLIC_SAFE_SOURCE_REVIEW",
        "evidence_state": "PRIMARY_DOCUMENTATION_REVIEW_ONLY",
        "canonical_question": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes?",
        "near_questions": [
          "Why does an MCP challenge request a scope absent from discovery?",
          "Are challenged scopes always a subset of scopes_supported?",
          "What scope is requested when the challenge omits it?",
          "Does a discovery scope list replace operation-specific consent?"
        ],
        "supported_claims": [
          {
            "claim": "No. MCP 2026-07-28 prohibits assuming a set relationship between challenged scopes and scopes_supported, and requires treating the challenge as authoritative for the current operation. For initial authorization it recommends using the challenge scope first; otherwise it recommends advertised scopes, omitting scope when scopes_supported is undefined. This does not itself grant consent.",
            "reliance": "DOCUMENTED_CAPABILITY_ONLY"
          }
        ],
        "not_demonstrated_claims": [
          "Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset.",
          "Buyer implementation, live runtime enforcement, settled payment, verified deletion or certification are not established.",
          "No expanded capabilities or licences for existing INDEX executables."
        ],
        "public_summary": "No. MCP 2026-07-28 prohibits assuming a set relationship between challenged scopes and scopes_supported, and requires treating the challenge as authoritative for the current operation. For initial authorization it recommends using the challenge scope first; otherwise it recommends advertised scopes, omitting scope when scopes_supported is undefined. This does not itself grant consent.",
        "related_record_ids": [],
        "source_review": {
          "source_type": "official_external_documentation",
          "source_title": "Model Context Protocol primary documentation: mcp authorization",
          "source_url": "https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/authorization.md",
          "checked_on": "2026-10-30",
          "candidate_record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE09-MCP-SCOPE-CHALLENGE-VERSUS-ADVERTISED-SCOPES-01-v1",
          "candidate_record_sha256": "2873468ff5e626a468768412962aff8f2a4f8cf92a14eb3ec8cdf9f1aaa14cb6",
          "method": "Primary documentation reviewed for the published bounded statement.",
          "deployment_tested_by_varexis": false,
          "revalidation": "The delivered snapshot preserves the review date shown. Recheck current primary documentation and deployment context before relying on present applicability; payment does not trigger fresh research."
        },
        "answer_policy": {
          "classification": "DOCUMENTED_WITH_DEPLOYMENT_BOUNDARY",
          "bounded_answer": "No. MCP 2026-07-28 prohibits assuming a set relationship between challenged scopes and scopes_supported, and requires treating the challenge as authoritative for the current operation. For initial authorization it recommends using the challenge scope first; otherwise it recommends advertised scopes, omitting scope when scopes_supported is undefined. This does not itself grant consent.",
          "required_buyer_context": "challenge; resource metadata; operation; current grant. Buyer deployment not inspected.",
          "missing_evidence": "A broader claim needs evidence matching the intended use. Payment does not upgrade the evidence state."
        },
        "private_boundary": "Raw logs, thresholds, private paths, source code, protected mechanisms and reconstruction-level details are excluded from public and paid delivery.",
        "decision_profile": {
          "schema": "varexis-vendor-evidence-review/1",
          "review_status": "documentation_review_only",
          "applicability_status": "Existing documented requirement; captured 2026-10-30; deployed behaviour unverified.",
          "checked_on": "2026-10-30",
          "claim_to_check": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes?",
          "documented_statement": {
            "status": "documented",
            "statement": "No. MCP 2026-07-28 prohibits assuming a set relationship between challenged scopes and scopes_supported, and requires treating the challenge as authoritative for the current operation. For initial authorization it recommends using the challenge scope first; otherwise it recommends advertised scopes, omitting scope when scopes_supported is undefined. This does not itself grant consent.",
            "source_ids": [
              "mcp-authorization"
            ]
          },
          "review_inference": {
            "status": "review_inference",
            "statement": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes? Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset. Scope negotiation differs from tool-list filtering under an existing token. This is an operational review inference, not an observed deployment outcome.",
            "source_ids": [
              "mcp-authorization"
            ]
          },
          "buyer_evidence_required": [
            "challenge",
            "resource metadata",
            "operation",
            "current grant"
          ],
          "review_condition": {
            "status": "varexis_review_policy",
            "statement": "Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset."
          },
          "unknowns": "The buyer implementation, effective authority, source-data completeness and actual business outcomes were not inspected.",
          "unknown_finding": {
            "status": "unknown",
            "statement": "No buyer deployment or transaction was observed."
          },
          "evidence_sources": [
            {
              "source_id": "mcp-authorization",
              "url": "https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/authorization.md",
              "final_url": "https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/authorization.md",
              "captured_at_utc": "2026-10-30T14:22:30.685963+00:00",
              "status": 200,
              "content_type": "text/markdown; charset=utf-8",
              "bytes": 25510,
              "sha256": "59bc8d07ef88538e4d4e539ca1c846c3ae3162e7911dc29453495cddeac18444",
              "title": "Model Context Protocol primary documentation: mcp authorization",
              "publisher": "Model Context Protocol",
              "checked_on": "2026-10-30",
              "capture_status": 200,
              "claim_review_completed": true,
              "hash_basis": "SHA-256 of captured HTTP response-body bytes; not a signature or factual guarantee.",
              "version_context": "Existing documented requirement; captured 2026-10-30; deployed behaviour unverified.",
              "rights_disposition": "Original bounded paraphrase with source attribution. Captured source body remains private; no source-body redistribution. Vendor documentation rights, code licences and marks are not transferred.",
              "reviewed_sections": [
                "Scope Selection Strategy"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_deployment": false,
          "commercial_reliance_boundary": "Documentation supports only the stated boundary. Existing licensed checkers analyse supported supplied declarations locally; they do not inspect provider accounts, verify live behaviour, enforce decisions or certify compliance.",
          "paid_value": {
            "decision_context": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes? Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset.",
            "free": "Complete source review, questions, provenance and limitations; free to read and save locally.",
            "single_request": "Unavailable for this publication-only record; historical saved retrieval is unchanged.",
            "evidence_receipt": "Unavailable for this publication-only record; no paid retrieval entitlement is added.",
            "excluded": [
              "Fresh source research",
              "Native provider integration or schema support",
              "Live inspection or runtime enforcement",
              "Payment settlement or verified deletion",
              "Certification or expanded licences"
            ],
            "integrity": "Hashes identify content versions; they do not prove factual truth or provide a signature."
          },
          "revalidation": {
            "trigger": "Recheck current primary documentation and the applicable API, service, account and configuration before reliance. No ongoing monitoring is included.",
            "specific_watch": "Scope Selection Strategy"
          },
          "buyer_relevance": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes? Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset.",
          "refusal_conditions": [
            "Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset.",
            "Do not infer deployment conformance, authority or successful outcomes from source documentation."
          ],
          "decision_context": {
            "operator": "Identity administrator or delegated-access reviewer",
            "scenario": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes?",
            "consequence": "Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset.",
            "confidence": "High for the explicitly bounded captured clause; conflicts and version limits retained; deployment untested."
          },
          "novelty_review": {
            "candidate_id": "ICE09-034",
            "disposition": "EXTENSION",
            "nearest_record_id": "VXI-EXT-PROCUREMENT-GITHUB-OAUTH-GRANTED-01-v1",
            "nearest_record_url": "/varexis-index/records/github-oauth-requested-granted-normalized-scopes.json",
            "nearest_record_sha256": "2feac61cd5d4950348aeb4a91d44f8c9d3b16d30698146db4e0ec42b5dca4b8e",
            "material_distinction": "Scope negotiation differs from tool-list filtering under an existing token.",
            "review_status": "PASS: source qualification plus independent reviewer challenge and resolved corrections"
          },
          "optional_selection": {
            "guide_id": "delegated-agent-identity-continuity",
            "guide_url": "/index-guides/delegated-agent-identity-continuity",
            "guide_manifest": "/varexis-index/decision-guides.json",
            "checker": {
              "product_id": "agent-tool-admission",
              "price_gbp_excluding_vat": 49,
              "purchase_url": "/index-access?route=agentic_pack_tool_admission_v1",
              "licence_scope": "Existing separate internal-use licence; subscriptions do not include the executable.",
              "benefit": "Optional local analysis of supported supplied declarations only; no native provider integration or verification is added."
            },
            "boundary": "Optional existing checker analyses its supported supplied declarations locally. It does not connect to the documented provider, import native provider exports, verify tokens, establish live outcomes or extend its schema or licence."
          },
          "exact_access": {
            "endpoint": "/mcp/catalogue",
            "tool": "get_publication_record",
            "arguments": {
              "record_id": "VXI-EXT-ICE09-MCP-SCOPE-CHALLENGE-VERSUS-ADVERTISED-SCOPES-01-v1"
            },
            "record_url": "/varexis-index/records/mcp-scope-challenge-versus-advertised-scopes.json",
            "original_mcp_search": false,
            "paid_saved_retrieval": false
          }
        },
        "niche": {
          "niche_id": "ice09-identity",
          "label": "Agent Identity, Credentials & Delegation",
          "classification_id": "identity",
          "classification_label": "Agent Identity, Credentials & Delegation",
          "topic_id": "identity",
          "buyer_intent": "Must an MCP scope challenge be a subset of advertised scopes? Use the actual challenge and consent policy, not an assumed discovery-list subset.",
          "comparison_role": "supplementary_discovery"
        },
        "paid_access_note": "The full published answer and boundaries are free. Paid access saves the selected route and source versions, with an unsigned receipt when purchased. Preview coverage before paying. Fresh research, bespoke assessment and protected evidence are excluded.",
        "service_route": {
          "request_guide": "/varexis-index/request.html",
          "request_workflow": "/varexis-index/request-workflow.json",
          "service_id": "single_request",
          "service_routes_url": "/varexis-index/service-routes.json",
          "payment_required": true,
          "availability_endpoint": "/api/index/capabilities",
          "operational_status": "AUTOMATIC_SERVICE_CAPABILITIES_GATED",
          "checkout_url": "/index-access"
        },
        "authority_boundary": "VAREXIS-INDEX informs evidence reliance. It does not provide advice, certification, deployment authority, security assurance, production approval, or guarantee.",
        "human_page": "/varexis-index/catalog.html#mcp-scope-challenge-versus-advertised-scopes",
        "machine_readable_record": "/varexis-index/records/mcp-scope-challenge-versus-advertised-scopes.json"
      }
    }
  ],
  "access": {
    "mode": "exact_http_only",
    "payment_required": false,
    "purchase_url": null,
    "mcp_preview_available": false,
    "paid_saved_retrieval_available": false,
    "natural_language_search_qualified": false
  },
  "boundary": "Catalogue additions are available free through the exact HTTP JSON links below. Enhanced natural-language discovery is not yet qualified for these records. They are outside MCP search, MCP preview and paid saved retrieval. No search qualification, executable capability or entitlement is added.",
  "content_sha256": "6071ff3621f23b3d874c153426e27f4f020d5cfd8607e87be39993989b7560bc"
}